I have decided to label fanservice in three different categories; sexual, continuity referential, and meta humor referential. Sexual is self explanatory and includes any sexualized or fetishized depiction of male and female characters. Continuity referential fanservice refers to self contained references within a single work, like showing the main character and their love interest 20 years later or bringing back an older character. This is certainly the smallest category, but it deserves distinction from the final category. Meta humor referential fanservice includes references that are not self contained within a work, like a joke from another show or some type of characterization that transcends its original work and becomes meta. Meta humor also incorporates fourth wall breaks and meta jokes that are not simply limited to references, but awareness and satirization of the animation medium. Additionally, these types of meta details can include voice casting, character designers, and script writers who ordinarily may not have been considered part of fanservice.
These three categories each have unique implications for the creators, audience, and the work itself. Combined with a bit of Azuma, Russell and my own crazy ideas, I will argue against the very idea of fanservice. I am starting to reject the notion that there is anything "fan" or "service" about fanservice. Each fanservice category will expand on these three ideas. First, that fanservice is not "something extra"; rather, it is demanded and expected. It is not simply what the fans want, but what they need. Second, that otaku itself cannot exist without fanservice. How can you obsess if there's nothing to obsess about? Third, that fanservice is directed at the animators and the animation industry more than the fans themselves. Who else has such an intimate understanding of anime? Who keeps producing anime?
This examination of fanservice will be very visual oriented and it will also require a great deal of contextualization since, by nature, that which actually constitutes fanservice cannot be easily identified without an obsessive understanding of the source material. Perhaps this is a job for otaku to explain. There will be a degree of nudity, cgdct, gar, moe, and many other things.
Sexual Fanservice
Sexual fanservice is probably the most easily recognizable and prominent form of fanservice. Ranging from innocuous fashion to full nudity, sexual fanservice represents the spectrum of content that presents a character in a manner that is attractive to the viewer. Before I discuss the implications of such fanservice, there are several concepts that I believe can help elucidate this vague and broad range of content.
First, consider zettai ryouiki (絶対領域), which has been literally deemed "Absolute Territory." This concept refers to the gap of exposed skin between knee-high socks and the hem of the skirt. There are multiple "grades" of ZR that denote the difference in the amount of skin shown. Contrary to the popular assumption that more skin is better, ZR preference varies by person. There's no scale or judgment associated with these grades; it's just a guide for quick reference. While I'm not doing a project on Japanese sock culture, I would also like to add that these sock grades are not limited to just ordinary socks. They also apply to stockings, those baggy socks that stereotypical delinquent girls wear, etc. Sorry guys, there's nothing for us.
![]() |
| I'm more of an A guy. It's about what you can't see. |
On that note, prepare for some indecent exposure. In the cornucopia of harem anime, I will use the most recent extreme to present these distinctions in fanservice: Highschool DxD. The x/cross is silent. Yes, it's a joke about breasts.
![]() | |
|
![]() |
| Why not both? |
Naturally, Rias gets quite upset that her territory is being encroached upon, but Akeno enjoys making Rias jealous. Their relationships are toyed with on many occasions, as Rias is the official "wife" and Akeno the second. This conflict plays out, much to Issei (and the viewer's) delight. It's difficult to write about aspects like voice and motion, so I included a link to the episode below.
Specials like these exemplify the traditional definition of fanservice. There is no narrative, the scenes weren't considered important enough to include in the regular series, and the entire point of watching is sexual gratification. However, I believe these specials can also poke holes in the traditional definition. While there may not be a narrative directly present, series fans understand that sex and eroticism are consistent with the narrative. After all, DxD is a show about Issei's harem and his dream of becoming the king of harems. When light novels are adapted into anime, time is a major constraint on narrative. There are only so many scenes that can be shown in a 13 episode series, so the lack of such scenes is more of a deficiency than something extra given to the fans. Additionally, these specials are expected and demanded. It would be incredibly unusual for specials not to be released with blurays (BD). Some of the content in these specials couldn't be broadcast in the first place. Shows like DxD usually air on AT-X, a special channel that allows for uncensored nudity and violence that would otherwise not be permitted on normal stations. Due to these limitations, BDs are equally important as animation studios often redraw lower quality frames and remove censorship. If a character didn't receive enough screentime or a particular scene from the novel wasn't animated, specials are the solution.
For a more academic perspective, I examined an article written by Dr. Keith Russell, professor of Communication and Design at the University of Newcastle in Australia. With a background in media and IT, anime is yet another visual medium to study. His article, titled "The Glimpse and Fan Service: New Media, New Aesthetics" appeared in the International Journal of Humanities in August 2008. His article explores the medium of animation as a means to circumvent social constraints. Before I explore the article itself, he makes several interesting points in abstract worth discussing.
"Japanese comics (Manga), and animations (Anime) arose in a time of limited social constraint. This allowed them to explore unmentioned topics and develop new aesthetics that involve Fan Service and the Glimpse. Fanservice is the random and gratuitous display of a series of anticipated gestures common in Manga and Anime. These gestures include such things as panty shots, leg spreads and glimpses of breast."
I will continue to dispute the randomness of fanservice (and Russell even goes on to contradict himself in this regard), but Russell makes the distinction of "anticipated gestures." His distinction is quite important to consider in the context of all fanservice, not just sexual, because it clarifies the relationship between the viewer and the viewed. Fanservice is not just a random, unexpected flash. Similar to the jump scares of campy horror movies, seasoned viewers know exactly when fanservice should occur and how it will develop.
"In their valorization they indicate a deep philosophical concern with the status of personal experience. These vagrant moments of libidinous possibility underwrite the anticipation of sensual fulfillment; they indicate the genuine access of the personal to a realm and/or moment of reality in which the physical and the imaginative are co-extensive. The connection between the eye and desire is re-established in defiance of the general requirement in society to deny the Glimpse. The Glimpse, in its mediated form as Fanservice, confirms the imagination as the dimension of the interpersonal: someone else also already understands the glimpse. This is perhaps the "darker" freedom because it offers to forgive the otherwise unique nature of vantage (I alone could see from where I stood). What I see you could also see; how I see you might also see. The Glimpse affords a new aesthetic understanding of being within the transitional world of the adolescent."
Russell's idea of a connection between intangible desire and tangible vision is quite important in understanding the content of sexual fanservice. This forbidden glimpse that he refers to is like the perspective of an ordinary glimpse in real life. The glimpse is like a snapshot, fleeting yet omnipresent. In this context, fanservice can be portrayed as wish fulfillment, but I also consider it a form of denial as these scenes never reach a climax. Before these scenes become vulgar, Issei conveniently passes out every time. This "darker freedom" that Russell refers to is a voyeuristic, shared gaze. To take his statement a step further, not only can others see as I see, but what we see was designed to be seen. In short, being naughty is a turn on.
![]() |
| You're supposed to look |
Russell starts by drawing a parallel between fanservice and 2channel, an anonymous online textboard akin to 4chan, which I described in my otaku life essay. As a matter of fact, 4chan was created as an English speaking 2channel, with text boards (2channel) and image boards (Futaba Channel). Ironically, Nishimura Hiroyuki, who created 2channel in 1999, purchased 4chan about a year ago. The point of comparison is that through anonymous communication, social norms can be bypassed. Tatemae can kick the can, honne is hear to stay. Specifically, Russell discussed how media creates unique perspectives that we can't see ordinarily. "While we have experiences of glancing and gazing in our everyday lives, prior to cinema and television, we did not experience glancing and gazing in the structured and differently constrained ways made possible by art objects. Through the formality of art we are able to explore and inspect, in reflective ways, the motivations of our perceptions, in a kind of aesthetic suspension." Human vision isn't like a movable camera that can view from many contexts, so as a medium, animation can play into desire at a more intricate level of detail.
How we look at images (semiotics) is equally important to understanding the role of sexual fanservice. The comparatively innocuous panchira (パンチラ), or panty flash, combines パンツ (panties) and ちらちら, an onomatopoeia for fluttering, flickering, or glancing. Russell explains that unlike the traditional gaze, glances are not superfluous. "Indeed, the superfluity of the sensuous always attends all information: there is more than enough; indeed, there is too much. The too much of the sensuous becomes the sensual. This implies that the sensuous is always inherently sensual: even the innocent details of a flower provide visual pleasure that belongs to the viewer and not the flower. In the case of the libidinous glimpse, the glimpse of the curve of the partly exposed breast, the apprehension is immediately sensual and there is no question of there being a surplus: the breast is the breast." To phrase this more simply, a sensual glimpse can be appreciated simply for what it is.
The simplicity of a glance is especially important in regards to the notion of reprieve from societal restrictions because the glance is free of the implications of the gaze. Contrasted with Laura Mulvey's conception of the gaze, Russell argues that "In the case of the gaze, the object of desire is located within a dramatic tension that implicates the viewer in the appropriation of the viewed. In the case of the glimpse, no such appropriation is implied. The drama, in the glimpse is given as a moment of free seeing. Such are the benefits of Fanservice." I still find this concept of a glance to be quite confusing, but I will try to put it in my own terms. While the gaze explains the subject/object relationship of viewer and viewed, the glimpse explains the agency of the object being viewed. The gaze is still visibly present and male via Issei, but the glance represents Rias and Akeno controlling how they are seen. To contextualize this in my example, Rias and Akeno are not simply bearing all to be gazed upon. Issei (and the viewer) receive a continuous series of short glimpses that Russell describes as "fetishistic" and "reassuring." Breasts can be appreciated for what they are, but the permission to view them (the glance) defines fanservice at a deeper level. As Russell humorously describes, "The Fanservice object is a kind of libidinous ornament, or totem, that not only reassures through confirmation but also announces the freedom of the possible that is located, in its origins, in the everyday viewing of the everyday world. There are, after all, breasts to be seen." Indeed there are; and much more.
Russell concludes by connecting the perspective of a glimpse to the content viewed. While I used the phrase "gratification" earlier, Russell notes that what fanservice aims to produce is mediation of desire and not gratification. Russell quotes Dino Felluga, a professor and scholar of critical theory at Purdue University, to explain this relationship between the viewer and viewed. "To come too close to our object of desire threatens to uncover the lack that is, in fact, necessary for our desire to persist, so that, ultimately, desire is most interested not in fully attaining the object of desire but in keeping our distance, thus allowing desire to persist. Because desire is articulated through fantasy, it is driven to some extent by its own impossibility." In other words, if our desires are actualized and become gratification, they're not merely desires anymore because we have achieved them. If we played out this example of fanservice to its logical conclusion, one could wager that Issei has sex with Rias and Akeno. Despite this, gratification never occurs...until the spinoff novel series that features all of Issei's children. Even then, gratification is subverted in the most carnal sense.
To summarize sexual fanservice and connect it to the larger concept of fanservice, depictions of sexuality circumvent reality to explore desire. By depicting sexuality via glimpsing, viewing is portrayed as permissible and acceptable in a liminal space. Most important of all, the glimpse is not something the viewer takes for themselves. It is provided as a given and the viewer should not feel ashamed or perverted for seeing it as someone else has seen it too. To put it simply, it's okay to look.
How does this understanding answer my previous questions? I consider sexual fanservice to be rather narrow in its scope, but by explaining the role of fanservice for the viewer, it's clear that fanservice is necessary and not extra.
Continuity Referential Fanservice
It's about time to get my head out of the gutter. I don't find this category of fanservice to be as significant as the other two, but it does introduce an important concept that exemplifies fanservice and connects it to subtler aspects of sexuality: shipping.
Continuity referential fanservice refers to self contained references within a single work, like character relationships and what if scenarios. The primary reason I consider this category to be less significant is that by definition, most anime series cannot employ it. In order to reference a continuity, continuity must exist. Not only does that eliminate a wide variety of genres that do not have an explicit narrative or context, but it also disqualifies anime that aren't fully adapted to the point that their continuity can be referenced. This type of fanservice is much more prevalent in manga, games, and light novels. Anime often serves as an advertisement or fanservice by itself for these other mediums, so many series end on an abrupt note or "read the novel to find out what happens next!" type of message.
Before I delve into shipping, my prior post on Macross Delta serves as a perfect example of continuity. Delta takes place in the greater Macross universe, so past events directly influence the present context. Mirage is the granddaughter of Max and Milia from SDF Macross. In one of the previous Macross series, Macross 7, the main heroine Mylene is one of the many daughters or Max and Milia. Idols from throughout the various Macross series often sing the same songs, like "My Boyfriend is a Pilot" (私の彼はパイロト) and "Do You Remember Love?" (愛覚えていますか). Mecha like the Valkyrie, Regult, and Macross are series mainstays. While robots and songs don't fulfill the same latent desire as sex, they function under a similar premise of wish fulfillment. Continuity functions similarly to meta humor except for the fact it is self contained instead of meta.
On the subject of shipping, Macross serves as a perfect example because it typically features a love triangle between the main character and competing love interests. Shipping is derived from the word relationship and involves wishing for characters to be in a relationship via online arguments (shipping wars), fanfiction, fanart, and so forth. I like to think of it as literally shipping a relationship; package it up and send it off. Shipping functions similarly to sexual fanservice because it is yet another form of desire. Some series have a canon pair based on the series canon, like Hayate and Freyja in Macross Delta. However, with competition comes dissent and many people preferred Mirage to win the fondly named Hayateb Owl (Hayate Bowl). Shippers commonly refer to their ships as OTP, or one true pair. Depending on their ship, they interpret the events of each episode to support their ship. Shipping wars often occur when an episode shifts fan favor to another side, like having Mirage hug Hayate without reciprocating any love for Freyja. Shippers often shorten names for their pairs, like HayaFre and HayaMira. Shippers who disagree often find it delusional how others interpret certain events or odds of winning, but just like sexual fanservice, desire is best left unresolved. Shipping can cause some controversy when popular ships "lose" or when a canon ship is revealed. Can you ship the canon pair? I sure think so.
![]() |
| Speculation is the heart of shipping |
![]() |
| Freyja Won (Vion, get it?) |
![]() |
| The ship has sailed |
As for how this relates to fanservice on the whole, continuities challenge the perception that fanservice is appreciated by fans. I differentiate long-term viewers from ordinary fans, so someone that didn't watch SDF wouldn't appreciate a reference in Delta. In general, I think academics only consider the audience in a discussion of fanservice. Staff who have worked on multiple entries in a show certainly qualify as long-term viewers. The most significant difference between continuity based fanservice and sexual is fandom. Animators can play into shipper fantasies, but they aren't necessary for shipping. Depending on how I analyze meta humor, perhaps fanservice could be more accurately defined as a creative mediation that enables viewers to interact with their desires.
Meta Humor Referential Fanservice
Finally, the meat of this paper. Meta humor fanservice refers to any type of reference that exists outside of a continuity. To truly understand meta humor as fanservice, I must first define meta.
Meta represents an abstraction of a concept that deals with the concept's foundation instead of the idea directly. To illustrate this point, I will use a joke. Prince Albert is a brand of tobacco. A common prank call was to dial up the local store and ask if they had Prince Albert in a can. The clerk would usually answer yes, to which the caller would reply that "you better let him out!" The joke of course being that Prince Albert is a brand, but if Prince Albert himself were actually in a can, you would naturally let him out. A modern version of this joke is "Is your refrigerator running?" Groucho Marx parodied this joke by asking, "'Do you have Prince Albert in a can?' He then turned to face the camera and said to the audience, 'Well, all the jokes can't be good, you have to expect that once in a while.'" Marx is playing with the idea of this joke being so cliched that the very process of telling it is a joke of its own.
In this case, meta humor broke the fourth wall between the audience and viewer by Marx acknowledging his audience. Not all meta humor breaks the fourth wall, but it often teases and rewards the viewer by acknowledging their experience. In abstract, this isn't that different from sexual fanservice or shipping because it toys with the audience's desires as a part of the production. While the audience doesn't make anime themselves per se, they are as much a part of the process as anyone else. Viewers assume the role of the audience, albeit unknowingly at times.
To recap the Brave Perspective (勇者パース), this innocuous pose from Brave Excaiser developed into a recurring trend in anime well outside the scope of the original medium. At first, it was self contained within the Brave series. After Fukuda referenced it in Gundam Seed and Seed/Destiny, it started to appear in other Sunrise mecha series. The pose is now so far removed from its original source that it can appear in anything from K-ON to Raildex. Before I explore a variety of examples of meta humor and references, an academic analysis will suffice.
While Azuma's article on otaku as database animals primarily deals with postmodernism and not fanservice, he makes several points on the behavior of otaku that directly relate to the presence of meta humor. At the beginning of his book, Azuma details the formation of otaku culture through Comiket, namely the continuous reproduction of derivative works that delineate content from an origin and embrace a postmodern ideal of simulacrum, which is "neither original nor copy." Among otaku, the presence of derivative works creates a non linear existence with no singular narrative. I believe that meta humor can be understood in this context as well. Azuma only considers derivative works within a singular context, like fans producing doujinshi of their favorite series. This may sound unrelated, but when I learned about Ukiyo-e (浮世絵) woodblock prints in visual culture, I was surprised how collaborative they were. Most works didn't have sole authorship, so when they were first introduced to foreign audiences, it was difficult to discuss them in a Western context as high art. I find anime to be quite similar, especially with the exchange of ideas. I think Azuma is a bit narrow in only considering fans and producers. Production spans a wide variety of tasks and creative personnel bring ideas from past work irrespective of whether or not their fans creative derivative work. So long as it isn't a part of a continuity, I think the definition of derivative can expand to include meta as well.
In addition to simulacra, Azuma highlights how otaku are creating alternate methods of communication because "social values and standards are already dysfunctional." While this paper isn't directly addressing postmodernism, perhaps this rationale explains why meta humor and references are created and propagated. I didn't really understand Azuma's diagrams of narrative structure, but I understand the sentiment that among otaku, dissemination of a grand narrative doesn't occur from a singular source. Rather, small narratives become a sum of their parts, like a database. As for how that relates to fanservice, meta humor is a perfect example of this postmodern narrative structure. References don't follow a grand narrative; they just kind of happen. They don't always originate from a single source, like Azuma's example of Anno teasing with derivative works in the End of Evangelion. Additionally, I was pleased to see Azuma acknowledge the role of staff in this database structure. Directors, character designers, mechanical designers, composers, and creative staff of all kinds can facilitate this rejection of grand narratives as much as fans do.
In regards to fanservice as a whole, I think meta challenges the definition most strongly. While sexuality clearly addresses the need for fanservice, meta also addresses this necessity by tying it to a rejection of grand narratives. In order to reject a narrative, meta is created to circumvent the linear aproach. Meta also calls into question whether "fan" or "service" accurately describe this process. First, meta muddles the relationship between viewer and producer to the point that it doesn't matter. Second, service implies that a grand narrative exists between producer and consumer. If no such relationship exists, then fanservice becomes part of the foundation of otaku as a means to communicate within the animated medium. As I mentioned earlier, fanservice may be a means for people to express their desire in a creative medium. The rejection of grand narratives, combined with the sharing and databasing of information, might support this claim.
Below are a variety of examples of meta humor and references.
Girls und Panzer
In case you ever wondered what that avatar I used on the discussion board was, it's from Girls und Panzer. There is almost no narrative present. In the series, people live on Academy Ships, which are aircraft carriers fashioned to support communities at sea. On these ships, girls attend school and study Sensha-dou (戦車道), or way of the tank. For sport, they maintain WWII-era tanks and participate in mock battles with other schools. Why not? This format allows for meta references via tank design and culture. Since the only narrative is that girls from schools fight in tanks, different schools can sport unique nationalities and tanks. There are schools that feature tanks from Japan, Germany, the Soviet Union, Italy, England, Finland, etc. The tanks provide fanservice via the accuracy of design and attention to detail in the mock battles. The girls provide fanservice, aside from simply being cute girls doing cute things (cgdct), by borrowing aspects of their character from the respective nationalities they represent. For instance, the girls of Jatkosoka High School represent Finland. During their appearance in one of the movies, the tank commander, Mika, is seen playing a kantele, a traditional plucked string instrument from Finland, specifically the Karelia region. Mika plays the Säkkijärven polkka while her crew operates their tank. This may sound like national pride and a bit of silliness, but Finnish tank commanders actually did this during the war, albeit with a pre-recorded track. The military discovered that when played at a particular frequency, the song could disarm Soviet radio controlled mines. References like these delve into recesses of meta that most people couldn't possibly know at first glance. There are far too many examples I could cite from GuP alone, but the underlying concept is that even when fans do not understand all of the references, the exchange of information in the database often facilitates new learning and interest.
| Mika with her kantele |
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9FL9IMr9kg
The link above is the polkka if you're curious. It actually sounds quite lovely and relaxing.
Military series like Girls und Panzer are a treasure trove of meta references. Other series include Upotte!! (anthropomorphized guns as cute girls), Strike Witches (cute girls with WWII fighter pilot theme), Kantai Collection (cute girls inheriting the spirits of WWII naval ships), and so forth. Many of the artists involved with these series, like Shimada Fumikane (島田フミカネ) and Shibafu (しばふ), also create doujinshi works in addition to their own official productions.
Joshiraku
I've always found ways to include Joshiraku, but this is the first time it's been appropriate. Joshiraku is a comedy about comedies. It also falls into the cgdct genre, but these five ordinary girls are rakugo-ka. While each episode starts with the conclusion of a rakugo performance, the rest of the show delves into disarray with no narrative other than the passage of time. Screencaps can't do the series justice, but this video link accurately sets the tone of the series.
https://streamable.com/t0j8
One particular example of meta in the series occurs in the last episode with the introduction of a new character, Uzattei Uzannu (宇座亭 ウザンヌ). Yes, her name is exactly what you're thinking of. She is annoying incarnate, derived from uzai (ウザイ). Parodying the awful trend incessantly introducing new characters that destroy the balance of the existing characters, Uzattei storms onto the stage in a Susano-o fashion and declares her intent outright. She hijacks the entire episode, sings her own version of the opening song with modified lyrics, and creates chaos for the amusement of the viewer. She even looks annoying!
The author of Joshiraku, Kumeta Kouji (久米田麹治), is infamous for series like Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei (さよなら絶望先生) that incorporate dark humor and too many fourth wall breaks to the point of his work not even having a fourth wall. His stories are incredibly nihilistic as well.
Shirobako
Shirobako employs a unique meta in that the series does have a narrative as a group of five girls work in the anime industry with the goal of creating an anime together, but it's highly referential to real life, with many of the characters being as authentic to their real world counterparts without portraying actual likenesses.
The series title itself is a reference to the animation industry. Prior to official release, VHS tapes were distributed to production staff in white boxes, hence the name. Below is the actual cast of characters.
![]() |
| From left to right, Toudou Misa (3D design), Sakaki Shizuka (Voice Actress), Miyamori Aoi (Production Assistant), Yasuhara Ema (Key Animator), and Imai Midori (Scriptwriter and Researcher) |
Fanservice might be a misleading term, but the contents incorporated with it have common traits that should be recognized. Fanservice is, without a doubt, more than just a panty flash or a minor reference. First and foremost, it serves as the language of otaku, who are disillusioned with grand narratives. Second, it builds a content database and community for viewers and producers to engage with. Finally, it enables the viewer, regardless of their position, to explore their desires in an animated medium, free of social norms and hierarchy. At first I questioned whether or not there may be a more appropriate word to describe fanservice, but an expanded definition serves the same purpose. After all, does fanservice really have to make sense in a linguistic sense?
If you made it this far, thank you for reading! Have a Kuma.






























