Monday, May 4, 2015

Blog Essay and Pictures

Japan’s sovereignty and military has a unique position in the world. After being defeated by the United States in World War II, Japan adopted a constitution that dramatically redefined its place in the world. As defined by Article 9 of the Japanese Constitution, Japan denounced war and revoked its right to the traditional tenant of national sovereignty. “Aspiring sincerely to an international peace based on justice and order, the Japanese people forever renounce war as a sovereign right of the nation and the threat or use of force as means of settling international disputes. In order to accomplish the aim of the preceding paragraph, land, sea, and air forces, as well as other war potential, will never be maintained. The right of belligerency of the state will not be recognized.” (Japanese Constitution).  However, this article was rapidly ignored. Just a few years after ratification of the Constitution in 1947, the United States lost China as an ally against communism with the establishment of the People’s Republic of China. Just a year after their victory in 1949 (Historian), the Korean War prompted MacArthur to deploy American troops stationed in Japan to the Korean peninsula. This action left Japan defenseless and lead to the formation of the National Police Reserve. Instead of the US Army, the Police Reserve protected Japan from foreign invasion using US military surplus. Within a few years, this Police Reserve was modified into the Japanese Self Defense Force that still exists today. The JSDF has continued to grow even though the Japanese Constitution has yet to be amended. By letter of law the JSDF arguably should not exist, yet America and the Japanese government support expanding its role in the region. This paradox sets the backdrop for discussions about Japanese militarism today.
            I personally do not hold a firm opinion about Japanese militarism. I am not Japanese nor do I possess a wealth of knowledge pertaining to the reality Japanese people faced during and after the war. Despite this, I will use works of art to explore different Japanese perspectives about past acts of war as well as future possibilities. These works of art range from paintings and sculptures to illustrations from anime and manga. In general, these images will not always directly represent militarism. When I first looked for these pictures, I had a very narrow view of militarism. I was looking for literal depictions of military equipment or references to past wars, but the effects of war range far beyond the initial act. The resulting occupation of Japan by the United States also exerted great influence on Japan. The Initial Post-Surrender Policy for Japan planned to both demilitarize Japan as well as to create a more Westernized Japan that would serve as an ally to the US and the United Nations. Intent of Westernization was explicitly stated in the documentation: “The encouragement of liberal political elements and the creation of conditions in Japan which will facilitate the emergence of a government with which the United Nations can deal.” (Policy). These policies did not just pertain to disarmament and economic recovery, but also to political and educational reform. Even though the Occupation formally ended in 1952 with the Treaty of San Francisco, many of the artists whose works I will use grew up during the immediate period as well as the following decades where the influence of these policies could finally be observed. These experiences, such as exposure to Mickey Mouse, greatly impacted their perspective. Therefore, the effects of militarism can still be observed even if the artworks do not directly seem related. With this in mind, I explored these images as well as their artists because their experiences with militarism may be tucked away in their artworks.
The first series of images I chose were from an iconic scene towards the end of the original Mobile Suit Gundam anime, created and directed by Tomino Yoshiyuki. Tomino was born in 1941, so he experienced the entirety of the Occupation during his childhood as well of the effects of it in his young adulthood. Tomino is credited for creating a major thematic change in mecha anime. Prior to Gundam, most robots were Super Robots, which were more fantastical and powerful. They would often be piloted by heroes who fought evil monsters that kind of look like Godzilla. In general, these robot shows put style and entertainment over substance. Some of the more famous Super Robots include Mazinger Z and Getter Robo. Tomino’s Gundam was later called the beginning of the Real Robot genre, with the real meaning realistic. The designs were considered to be more realistic because they were loosely based on modern technology and scientific understanding. The stories and themes were more adult and could address any number of issues instead of focusing solely on ‘villain of the week’ entertainment. Other famous Real Robot series include Macross, Patlabor, Votoms, and Full Metal Panic. This genre change is significant because it allowed for other elements of art to enter the greater mecha genre. One of the underlying factors of Real Robot is that because they are more realistic, they often appear in more realistic settings like the military or police. Instead of being piloted by heroes, they’re used by regular soldiers who often fight one another. They often look more industrial and humanoid and frequently fail just like regular machines. Tomino’s desire to make anime more of a high art directly stems from the effects of militarization. He explained that when he was younger, “basically manga did exist, but they were a thing that was read quickly and then discarded. You could find it in the trash boxes in every home. Also, there was no anime as we know it today. What we did have were moving manga—cartoons, of course. There were also these longer works created by Disney. But in general, the world of animation, the world of manga, was not considered to be high art.” His early exposure to Western animation influenced his own works. He goes on to explain, “Each class would go to the movie theatres and watch these long form Disney movies. They were the only kinds we were allowed to see. In retrospect, however, I can see that perhaps this was part of the educational effort directed by the GHQ, the occupation forces of Japan. In other words, I felt that these films, now that I look back on it, were something that was forced. Not forced on the Japanese, but given to the Japanese to watch, and Japanese people were expected to absorb the lessons there. However, when I look back to my first reactions to seeing these long works, I must have been around 10 years old. I remember still being extremely moved at the technology and the perseverance at the people who made these films. After all, these animated films were all drawn by hand. They were all in beautiful color, and they were a wonderful thing I was able to be exposed to. I would not have been able to be exposed to them if the school had not sent me to see these films.” Tomino explained further that he was critical of early Disney animation. He felt it was jerky and simplistic, which would illegitimatize animation. (Interview). While animation cannot be easily seen in 2d images, Tomino’s past experiences help to explain some of the themes in his artworks. Below are a series of images that all portray a similar scene from the final episode of Mobile Suit Gundam. In Amuro and Char’s final battle at A Baoa Qu, the Gundam and the Zeong have both been heavily damaged. In a last ditch effort to defeat Char, Amuro abandons the Gundam as it walks out into a shaft. The Gundam’s computer, which has studied Amuro’s tactics throughout the series, is able to hit the head of the Zeong, but is destroyed in the process as Char uses the mega particle cannon to take out its right leg and bring the Gundam to its knees. This particular scene is called “The Last Shooting” because it marks the last shot that brought an end to the One Year War. Although the Gundam is heavily damaged and ultimately destroyed, it was able to stand strong to bring the war to an end. This strength embodies the Zen Buddhist concept of gaman, or perseverance in the face of adversity. I think this principle reflects some of the emotions of a post war society. I envision that most people were rather upset with the destruction of their everyday lives. Despite this, America offered to help and society needed to be rebuilt. Instead of grieving or mourning, Japan worked hard to become successful. Gundam may have been a lighter method to revisit the loss of war that was skipped over during the heyday of rapid political and social change.
Departing slightly from mecha, Kancolle is one of the more literal depictions of Japanese militarism. Kancolle is short for Kantai Collection (Fleet Collection). The purpose of the game is to build your fleet featuring boats from the Imperial Japanese Navy. The twist is that all the boats are anthropomorphized as cute girls. You probably didn’t think the three images were related in any context before I said that. Kancolle is particularly interesting because of some of the political outrage it has caused. Many foreign critics believe there is frequently Japanese revisionism in regards to historical texts and recounting of events. The boats themselves aren’t really works of art in a traditional sense, but these ships are often representative of Japanese imperialism since they were used in the war effort even if they did not directly transport troops to occupied nations. The series has many different artists who all bring their unique styles together to design different characters to represent the boats. Many of the boats in the Japanese fleet were not just tools of war, but symbols of their culture. In this case, the Kongou is borrowed from the name of Mount Kongou and means indestructible. The Yamato was of much greater cultural significance. As the lead ship of the Navy and the most heavily armed battleship in history, it signified the prowess of Japanese engineering and their resolve to resist Western powers. Yamato is also the name prescribed to older Japan as well as the “original” Japanese race. Yamato damashii represents the collective spirit of the Japanese people.  Yamato means great harmony and is somewhat related to the aesthetic wa that we examined earlier in the year. Space Battleship Yamato was a rather famous portrayal of the battleship Yamato that tried to re-instill a sense of pride and masculinity in Japan. Some critics have claimed these moe depictions soften the horrors of Japanese imperialism, but the existence of deeper political themes is often contested by players who just want to play a fun game.
Trying to move away from otaku culture, Aida Makoto’s artwork harshly critiques Japan’s militarism and draws some very interesting parallels to aforementioned Tomino. Frankly, I burst out laughing when I first saw his painting Zaku because I couldn’t believe that a contemporary artist actually referenced Gundam in a serious environment. Zakus are the primary mobile suits of the Republic of Zeon in the Universal Century timeline in the Gundam universe. Although not all UC Gundams are directed and written by Tomino, the Republic of Zeon is very heavily related to the Empire of Japan as it fights against the Earth Federation (America) for independence. The most significant comparison between Zeon and Japan is that their ultimate goal was to create the Side Co-Prosperity Sphere, which is obviously referencing the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere that the Empire of Japan sought to create. Most of these Zakus in the painting are equipped with their standard bazookas, heat hawks, and machine guns. A lot of them are destroyed or have fallen over and the work looks very similar to the Ash Colored Mountains of salarymen. It’s not abundantly clear what is destroying these Zakus, as they usually fight other mobile suits instead. Several of the Zakus have their arms extended in a motion like they’re saying “Onward!” or “Follow me!” which is reminiscent of a call to arms. Perhaps he is criticizing the increasingly conservative otaku and politicians who want Japan to rearm and become more like the Japan of old. I wouldn’t agree with this interpretation though because Gundam is very anti-war and while Aida is not very young, Tomino is much older than him and has a different understanding of post war Japanese life.
Gate Ball and Air Raid both make very harsh statements about the war and Japan’s imperialism. Gate Ball shows older Japanese people literally making a game of croquet out of the lives of other Asian nations by beheading them and smacking them around with a mallet. This game is conducted under the guise of the Co-Prosperity Sphere and each one of the heads represents a culture from different parts of Southeast Asia. Air Raid shows colorful Zero fighter planes in a figure 8 firebombing Manhattan. I think this painting is very similar to the Gundam because it can represent resilience. Japanese people may have felt a lot of anger towards the US for the air raids it conducted on mainland Japan, which killed hundreds of thousands of civilians and left millions homeless. However, there was no opportunity for revenge or grief. People had to rebuild society so they would have a roof to sleep under and food to eat. Showing Manhattan engulfed in flames just like Tokyo was may be a bit cathartic to people with pent up emotions, but it also helps others understand the grief of the victims of these air raids. It humanizes their loss by removing past incidences from their context. Firebombing may sound legitimate during a war, but it becomes much harder to bear in a modern context when that tension of conflict is no longer present.
Going back in time a bit, the 1950s and 1960s of Japan present a lot of interesting art pertaining to protest of social institutions and the military occupation. These two decades of Japanese history are often forgotten, not so much because the Occupation changes were not dramatic, but that more pertinent issues arose via the Cold War and the Korean War, ironically referred to as the Forgotten War in America. Many liberal artists criticized the conservative government that negotiated the peace treaties with America. These peace treaties felt unequal, as Japan was held to stricter standards than other Axis powers. They felt that the negotiated peace was bogus and that a new war had emerged within Japan of Western versus Japanese ideology. Although these military leaders were initially thrown out of power by the GHQ, they were eventually reinstated because they had a greater fear of liberals promoting communism in Japan. These conservatives often kowtowed to American demands and pushed treaty resigning through quickly while ignoring more serious issues that impacted the daily lives of Japanese citizens. Many Japanese people protested the pro-American terms, especially those pertaining to the creation and expansion of military bases in Japan, namely Okinawa. One artist who painted scenes from these protests was named Nakamura Hiroshi. The Sunagawa incident was one such protest that inspired his works. Many farmers had their land confiscated by the US military as they expanded airfield length at the Okinawa base. These farmers clashed with Japanese police as they protested to keep their land. Another incident was the Girard Incident, where a Japanese woman was shot dead at a firing range for trespassing to collect spent shell casings for scrap metal. The woman had been collecting any scrap metal she could find because there were still food shortages and starvation in Japan. People tried to support themselves by any means necessary, even if it meant trespassing on a base to steal. Nakamura’s later works were heavily influenced by the firebombing he survived as a child. He described the series of bombings by calling every day “Russian Roulette”. Other artists like Ikeda Tatsuo depicted the plight of women in post war Japan. Many women lost their fathers, husbands and brothers in the war and needed financial support. Many of them turned to foreigners because they were left with a false choice of poverty or humiliation. There were also paintings of Japanese soldiers returning from the dead because many artists feared that the US would try to pull Japan into the Korean War. Unfortunately they were correct, but the protests were successful enough that they were able to avoid armed conflict and still have to this day. While these protests did not succeed in creating lasting change, they made a strong statement about the negative social effects of militarism. Perhaps it was ironic given their past attempts at imperialism.
Although these artworks are merely a sampling of Japanese impressions of militarism, they make a very strong case that Japan has lost part of its own culture in the turmoil. The new constitution and treaty created many reforms that helped to empower women and minorities under Japanese law. However, the treaty wasn’t made entirely on the peoples’ terms and heavily encouraged Japan to be complicit with American foreign policy. Politicians did not succeed in securing Japanese neutrality, and the people were clearly outraged by the forced Westernization of Japan. The issue was not that these changes were unwanted. Rather, the future of Japan should be decided by the Japanese people. These post-war events created the setting of a Westernized Japan, rich and successful with commerce but subservient to the US. In the wake of success these conditions became harder to criticize, but many artists still present themes of peace for future generations.

Below are the images used throughout my essay